Posted: 02/23/2016

Researchers Say BMI Is an Inaccurate Measure of Health

Bmi_calculator

Body mass index, or BMI for short, is commonly used as a quick and easy way to determine if someone is within a healthy weight range. However, many health care professionals have been criticizing this measure for years, and a new study from UCLA researchers supports the argument that BMI is not correlated to overall health. As one of the study’s co-authors, Jeffrey Hunger, put it: “This should be the final nail in the coffin for BMI.”

What’s Wrong with BMI?
Body mass index is a ratio of height to weight (to be exact, it’s a person’s weight in kilograms divided by the square of the person’s height in meters.) It’s intended to provide a quick estimate of a person’s amount of body fat, allowing health care providers to determine if the individual is a healthy weight. In fact, many people center their weight loss or diet plan goals around BMI numbers. A BMI under 18.5 is considered underweight, between 18.5 and 24.99 is considered a normal weight, over 25 is considered overweight, and over 30 is considered obese. However, there are several problems with this method of estimation.


Standard Body Mass Index Graph

First of all, the BMI equation doesn’t distinguish between fat and muscle, meaning that a muscular athlete could be classified as overweight or even obese. The equation also doesn’t take into account location or different types of body fat. Visceral fat, which develops around muscles and organs and can change the way the body balances energy needs, is more harmful than subcutaneous fat, which develops directly under the skin. There’s no way for the simple BMI equation to distinguish between those types of fat that are relatively healthy and those that are less so.

The new study from UCLA suggests that BMI is not just an inaccurate measure, but that there’s no correlation between BMI and overall health. The researchers looked at data from over 40,000 individuals who participated in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey between 2005 and 2012, and they found no link between BMI and several important measures of cardiometabolic health, including blood pressure, triglycerides, cholesterol, glucose, insulin resistance, and C-reactive protein. This supports previous research from the study’s lead author, A. Janet Tomiyama, finding no clear connections between weight loss and improvements related to blood pressure, diabetes, blood glucose levels, and cholesterol.

Based on the study, an estimated 54 million Americans who are classified as overweight or obese based on their BMI are actually in good health. Conversely, an estimated 21 million people whose BMI puts them in the ‘normal’ range could actually be considered unhealthy based on cardiometabolic measures. The researchers recommend that people focus on eating well and exercising on a regular basis, rather than obsessing over weight or BMI as a measure of health.

By HelpRx Staff Writer

Get your Prescription Discount Card and automatically SAVE on over 50,000 drugs nationwide.

Helprx_branded_card_desktop Click-here-redbg

About the HelpRx.info Blog

HelpRx.info is staffed by experts in the prescription medication industry. Get the latest health, medical news and pharmaceutical news that can save you money and allow you to take charge of your healthcare. With frequent updates about the prescription drug industry as well as medicine news, you'll gain an insider look into the industry and learn more about how to get the best price on your prescriptions while not sacrificing quality. Subscribe to the HelpRx.info pharmacy blog through our RSS feed or get updates by liking HelpRx.info on Facebook and following HelpRx.info on Twitter.

About HelpRx

Our discounts provide you access to negotiated prices on your prescription drugs at your local pharmacy. We can provide these because we're partnered with OptumRx, a BIG pharmacy benefit provider that provides prescription coverage for MILLIONS of people like you.

About ScriptRelief

Script Relief, the creator of the NPSN card and HelpRx discounts, helps consumers save an average of 50%, and up to 75%, off their prescriptions.

Popular Post

 

Get your Prescription Discount Card and automatically SAVE on over 50,000 drugs nationwide.

Helprx_branded_card_desktop Click-here-redbg

Popular Post

 

About the HelpRx.info Blog

HelpRx.info is staffed by experts in the prescription medication industry. Get the latest health, medical news and pharmaceutical news that can save you money and allow you to take charge of your healthcare. With frequent updates about the prescription drug industry as well as medicine news, you'll gain an insider look into the industry and learn more about how to get the best price on your prescriptions while not sacrificing quality. Subscribe to the HelpRx.info pharmacy blog through our RSS feed or get updates by liking HelpRx.info on Facebook and following HelpRx.info on Twitter.

About HelpRx

Our discounts provide you access to negotiated prices on your prescription drugs at your local pharmacy. We can provide these because we're partnered with OptumRx, a BIG pharmacy benefit provider that provides prescription coverage for MILLIONS of people like you.

About ScriptRelief

Script Relief, the creator of the NPSN card and HelpRx discounts, helps consumers save an average of 50%, and up to 75%, off their prescriptions.

Helprx_savings_logo

About Our Savings:

HelpRx.info is a discount pharmacy service, partnered with a leading pharmacy benefit manager. We negotiate lower prices on prescription medications, that we pass on to our members for free. There is no cost to use our cards and coupon, and anyone can take advantage of our discounts, regardless of healthcare coverage.

Our savings assurance of “up to 75% off” comes from historical data from actual claims. This data includes savings for both brand name and generic medications.